How to Adapt Skit-and-Clue Murder Mystery Games for Different Performance Styles
5 min read Updated 3 September 2026
If you’ve ever looked at our murder mystery games and thought, “This is brilliant, but how do I make it work for my group?” then we may have what you need!
If you’re looking for a much more flexible format game than our regular formats and are willing to put a little bit of time in to customise games – then the skit and clue based games are exactly the style of game you need as your “base template”.
This format is designed to run in a specific way, but it is the EASIEST game in our catalogue to flex. And the easiest to adjust without having to learn how to write murder mysteries yourself!
How they normally run:
You get two short skits (around five minutes each) to introduce the suspects and each murder, plus a big bank of clues delivered in two batches (100 clues per batch, 200 total). Guests swap, trade, and compare what they’ve learned until the solution clicks into place. An inspector overseas the “game” and provides the solution at the end.
Because players don’t need to memorise long character back stories, and because the plot is intentionally straightforward, this style is perfect for novice performers, mixed-confidence groups, and hosts who want something that feels interactive without being intimidating.
Because there are two short performances and TWO murders – it’s also entertaining to watch and get involved as an audience.
How they adapt:
Each game comes with the bank of clues, but also a short hand set of character backgrounds, mystery synopsis and solution. This makes the games incredibly easy to pull around as all the information you need as an editor is readily available to adjust.
There are lots of ways these games can be adapted, but we’ll cover three of the most common below.
Below are three reliable ways to adapt skit-and-clue games to suit different performance styles
Make your cast work to provide the clues.
Best for: confident ad-libbers and hosts who want a more immersive feel or who have a very small audience.
Here’s how to do it:
1. Give each cast member the back story from the instructions, any clues that relate to them, and the full solution.
This will give the cast a “short hand” background and enough information and facts to ad lib as they move around the room chatting to guests. Treat the clues as facts and share those clues naturally in conversation.
2. Set a clear improv boundary.
The goal is to embellish, not invent new plot. If your cast members are confident ad-libbing then make sure they don’t make up too much, the clues and back story and solution should give them enough structure to improvise without derailing the plot. And because they know the solution, they’re less likely to spoil it.
Change how the clues are delivered (and make them physical)
Best for: smaller immersive parties, people who love evidence based case files.
The clue bank is one of the easiest parts of this format to customise. If you want to shift from “paper swapping” to something more theatrical, you can convert clues into physical evidence.
A simple example:
If a clue says, “There are rats in the hotel,” you can use a stuffed toy rat, attach an evidence tag, and suddenly you’ve got a prop in the room guests can review.
Ways to adapt clue delivery:
- Photographs: Set up a crime scene board and create photographs of suspects, props and information based on the clues normally provided. Guests can examine the photos on the board. OR you can give teams envelopes containing all these photographs.
- Documents: convert some clues into witness statements, or other invented documents e.g. newspaper articles that cover the same information that is provided in the clues.
- Props: convert the clues into physical props (like the rat suggestion above) and leave them around the room for guests to find.
You can also remove the skit introduction if you really want to – though we advise against it as it makes for a poor denouement. Everyone likes someone to accuse!!
Condense the clue bank from sentences to paragraphs
Best for: shorter events, smaller groups, audiences who prefer chatting to swapping lots of slips.
Two hundred clues can be wonderfully chaotic – but not every group wants that level of paper-trading.
If you’d like a calmer, more streamlined version, you can condense the clue bank into fewer, richer pieces of information.
How to condense clues without breaking the mystery:
1. Merge clues that say similar things. – If three clues all point to the same fact, combine them into one stronger clue.
2. Remove clues that don’t add plot value. – If a clue doesn’t build motive, opportunity, timeline, relationships, or alibis, it may be safe to cut. There are always a few spare “filler” clues in the mix.
3. Remove some red herrings. – for very small events you may want to cut back on the number of red herrings or clues that implicate the wrong person in the murder. This is more important for younger groups. We’ve adapted these for teenage parties before and reducing the red herrings often helps.
4. Create “things you know” flash cards to be given to guests. – Instead of handing out dozens of tiny clues, give each guest a larger information paragraph that only they know. Guests then circulate and compare notes in conversation, rather than swapping paper constantly. This approach keeps the social deduction and information exchange of the game while reducing admin and speeding up pacing.
Conclusion: of all our games this is the most flexible and easiest to adjust
Skit-and-clue games are one of the easiest murder mystery formats to customise because:
- The skits establish the suspects quickly.
- The clue bank carries the investigation.
- Players don’t need deep back-story knowledge to participate.
So whether you want a light-touch host-led party, a prop-heavy immersive experience, or a streamlined “chat and deduce” event, you can adapt the same core game to fit.
Many hosts use a combination approach, mixing in evidence, and props, photographs, cast ad libbing and flashcards for each guest to create one glorious event that’s similar but also entirely different to the game as it was written.
Just reach out if you need the game in an editable format as you want to adjust it and we can send it to you in MSword.