Red Herring Games

The story so far

The case

Europe, 1946. The war is over—but not all secrets were buried.

Step into the shadowy world of the Monuments Men, the real-life heroes who risked everything to rescue Europe’s stolen treasures. Decades after the guns fall silent, a bricked-up German cellar is breached, revealing the remains of a missing American officer—and a trove of cryptic clues that land in your hands. In the aftermath of WWII, the Monuments Men scoured Europe to save priceless art from destruction. But not every masterpiece was recovered—and not every hero made it home.
Now, you’ve inherited the final clues to a decades-old mystery

Can you crack the codes, connect the clues, and solve the cold case that history left behind?

Inside the case

Everything you need is in the box

  • Immersive solo narrative

    Become the detective in a gripping, historically-inspired story where every artifact tells a tale.

  • Authentic replica documents

    Telegrams, coded letters, photographs, postcards and more, painstakingly recreated for a hands-on experience.

  • Challenging puzzles

    Decipher ciphers and codes based on real Allied techniques: playfair, knock code, letter substitution, caesar ciphers and more.

  • Historical research tools

    Newspaper clippings, suspect profiles and wartime records to help you piece together the mystery.

  • No digital needed

    100% offline play: no websites, no apps, no "support pages gone missing". All solutions are sealed in the box.

  • Help if you need it

    Need a hint? Reach out to the Red Herring Games team, or join fellow sleuths in our Cosykiller Facebook group.

Replica military paperwork from the case, stamped classified and confidential

The evidence

What’s in the box

  • 4 photographs
  • 1 field guide
  • 5 postcards
  • 2 newspaper articles
  • Map and poster
  • List of missing artworks
  • 12 military documents
  • Telegram and coded note
  • Code solutions notebook
  • Final solution envelope
The documents laid out: a Western Union telegram, postcards and the officer’s Field Service Pocket Book

Up close

The documents

  • Replica postcards and a Western Union telegram
  • A newspaper cutting about a hidden masterpiece found in Altaussee, and a cipher grid
  • A map and a military personnel record

Why us

Why choose Red Herring Games?

  • Award-winning design

    Created by our in-house crime-writing team with 18 years of experience and a passion for immersive storytelling.

  • Customer support

    We’re here if you need help: no bots, just real people (and occasionally our office dogs).

  • Offline gaming

    No digital components. Everything you need is in the box.

  • Replay-ability

    Once solved you have the answer, but there is no requirement to damage any of the contents to solve the case, which means you can pass on the game to a friend to enjoy.

The small print

The details

Number of players
1–6 players
Occasion
Date night

Before you buy

Frequently Asked Questions

If you can’t find an answer to your specific question do reach out via email or phone.

How is it different from a party game?

A case-file mystery is for 1 to 3 players: solo, as a couple or with a close friend. You sift through documents, photos, codes and clues to unravel the story at your own pace. The focus is on deep investigation, logic, timelines and details, and there are no scripts or acting.

A party game is for a group: everyone plays a character, and one of you is the murderer. More on the difference.

Who will enjoy it?

Puzzle lovers, introverts, or anyone after a quiet, hands-on challenge. You need lots of time to read and think.

How difficult is it to play?

Our case file mysteries are designed to be difficult. If you have played others on the market – do not expect ours to be as easy to solve.

The best way to describe this game is as an exploded book. Everything you need to know is in the game, but it’s your job to piece it together, plot twists and all. The solution is satisfying, the clues to get to it are in the game but they are not obvious. So don’t expect it to be easy. Only you decide when you are ready to open the solution and see if you were right. It’s not unusual to decide to sleep on it a few days.

This game takes 2-4 hours to play if you are decoding all the ciphers yourself. There is a code solution booklet which you can use to obtain the translations which will speed you up. However it’s designed to be a “slow burn” game. The idea is to take your time to digest all the information and spot the clues you need to solve it.

This is what we call a “Narrative Case File Experience”. It relies on reading and cross referencing information within the documents. There are no “puzzles” to solve, but there are ciphers consistent with the period to decode.

How fast will my order arrive?

Approx arrival times for 48 hour tracked and airmail are:

  • UK – 3-4 working days (the Royal Mail don’t guarantee 48 hours and it often enters the system at the end of the working day).
  • Europe 7-10 working days
  • Rest of World – 14-28 working days

If you elect for expedited shipping – we use a Courier or Royal Mail Next Day Delivery within the UK; and a courier outside the UK.

Approx arrival times on Expedited shipping are:

  • UK – 1-2 working days
  • Europe – 3-7 working days
  • Rest of World – 3-9 working days
Where is my order?

We have no machines in the office that handle distribution. All orders at Red Herring Games are handled and processed by real people and we always endeavour to ship orders within 48 hours.

If you received a dispatch confirmation email from us, we received your order and have shipped it.

So if it hasn’t arrived when you were expecting, it means, sadly, that your order may have fallen victim to “natural causes”.

Mail men occasionally drop packages in puddles, trains are occasionally robbed, boats sink, and conveyor belts sometimes chew up post.

If the order hasn’t arrived when you were expecting just get in touch so we can see if we can find out what has gone wrong and get a replacement to you ASAP!

International shipping can take as much as 21 days – however, if you need it quickly and fear it may have fallen victim to the postal gremlins, contact us and we will see what we can do to help!

Why are physical games more expensive to ship to the USA?

Physical goods (paper, ink, and boxes) are subject to international trade tariffs and customs processing fees. Because digital downloads are not "physical goods," they currently bypass these import taxes entirely.

More like this

You might also like

All accessories & gifts →

Not quite right?

There are plenty more to choose from

Answer three quick questions and we'll narrow it down to the ones that fit your group.