Sly Shyster
Senator.
A democrat of ambition and drive, Sly is a man who knows how to press the flesh and win votes.
Male
Give us a call now: UK +44 (0)2030 112 215 USA 646-568-9880
The story so far
Al Scapone – the Godfather of the infamous Scapone family and master criminal lies dead ”“ gunned down in his own club!
Word of this hit gets out and the whole balance of power in the city could be thrown into chaos. Al’s murder needs to be resolved – and fast – to restore the credibility of the family.
The question is: can the killer be found, or some scapegoat framed, before the end of teh night?

The line-up
Each guest plays one of these characters, and every one of them has something to hide.
6 suspects · 2 female, 2 male, 2 any gender
Senator.
A democrat of ambition and drive, Sly is a man who knows how to press the flesh and win votes.
Male
Al Scapone’s right hand man.
With sleek hair and a pencil moustache, Rick may look respectable in his tux, but he’s never without his sidearm, leg arm, rear waistband arm, up the sleeve arm…
Male
Opera singer.
Beautifully dressed in a stunning evening gown, Francesca’s dark eyes and fulsome lips have proved a strong temptation for many a man. Fortunately, her family have always been there to see off any unsuitable suitors!
Female
Scapone’s driver.
Mechanically minded and heavy on the accelerator pedal, No-brakes McGraw gets Scapone places – fast!
Any gender
Scapone’s ditzy niece.
Young and flirtatious, Margarita always dresses dangerously in low cut blouses and short skirts, luring in unsuspecting men who are then deemed unsuitable and disposed of by her protective uncle.
Female
Scapone’s accountant.
Always clutching a mechanical calculator, you can tell by the expensive clothing Robin earns far more than most accountants.
Any gender
The matriarch of the Scapone family.
Larger than life and in floral clothing, Ma has never really moved with the times and is still often found in her kitchen, stirring bolognaise sauce, whenever the family come to visit.
Female · Joins at 8 players
Scapone’s muscles.
With a bodybuilder’s physique clearly visible under his loosely fitting tux, it’s easy to see why Toni became Scapone’s Mr Fixit. Even among family, Toni’s trusty violin case is never very far away.
Male · Joins at 8 players
Scapone’s girlfriend.
Connie has always been desirable and has been a temptation to many, wearing clothing that accentuates her curves, revealing just enough to tantalise!
Female · Joins at 10 players
Scapone’s cousin.
Shifty and prone to violence, or at least sudden flashes of rage, Mickey wears his tux with a difference – he looks good and he knows it!
Male · Joins at 10 players
Club singer.
A distant relative of Scapone’s, Ann has a sensuous voice and a great body to match it! She’s usually seen in a very slinky number.
Female · Joins at 12 players
Barman.
With black shirt and trousers, Franc is used to working behind the bar, enjoys the banter and knows all the cocktail-shaker moves.
Male · Joins at 12 players
Scapone’s quiet niece.
Bookish and reserved, Penny is very unlike any of her cousins, wearing dull drab clothing and thick glasses.
Female · Joins at 14 players
Scapone’s left hand man.
A mirror image of Rick Otta, Roberto sometimes looks alike too and definitely has the same penchant for firearms!
Male · Joins at 14 players
Dancer.
Young, vivacious and dangerously blonde, Sherry Shimmy is a girl who knows exactly how to strut her stuff.
Female · Joins at 16 players
Trumpet player.
A strong jazz musician, Danny is often seen in a white jacket and dark trousers, ready to sing and play for an audience.
Male · Joins at 16 players
Waitress.
Young and eager to please, Ruby has a white pinny over her black dress and tries her best to keep all the customers happy.
Female · Joins at 18 players
Al Scapone’s nephew.
Young but in well-pressed clothes, Lenny is a real chip off the old block and not a boy to mess around!
Male · Joins at 18 players
Dancer.
With short, bobbed hair and an equally short dress, Bunny just loves jazz and her tassels are guaranteed to swing with her thing!
Female · Joins at 20 players
Reporter for the Chicago Tribune.
Scruffily attired, Ed is always at the front of any action with his notebook and pen to the ready.
Male · Joins at 20 players
How it plays
Send the invitations a couple of weeks ahead. On the night nobody has to learn lines or act: everyone reads from their own booklet, and the Inspector keeps it moving.
Yes. Put the video Inspector on and play a suspect yourself, or read the Inspector's part and run the show. The answer is only at the very end of the Inspector's booklet, so nobody stumbles on it.
The Red Herring difference
Plenty of party kits pick the killer at random on the night, or tell them in their booklet. We played enough of those to start writing our own.
Who's the killer?
Ours: Written into the plot from the first page, and every clue leads to them.
Others: Picked at random on the night, so the clues can't really point anywhere.
Does the killer know?
Ours: No. Nobody can let it slip, and the murderer plays detective with everyone else.
Others: Usually told in their booklet. One 'oops' and the game is over.
Is everyone a suspect?
Ours: Yes. No spare parts: every character has secrets to keep and questions to answer.
Others: 'Optional' characters who can be left out, and often feel like it.
Who wrote it?
Ours: Our own authors, from scratch. We know every clue, so we can answer questions and tweak it for you.
Others: Often bought in and resold, so nobody on the phone knows the plot.
Nobody's character booklet says who did it. The solution is only at the very end of the Inspector's booklet, so the host can print, assemble and still play along. In a printed kit that booklet arrives in a sealed envelope to avoid anyone accidentally seeing the answer.
What's in the box
Everything you need to run the perfect party is in the game pack. We do all the hard work, so you can focus on having fun.
Download it the second you pay, or have us print, assemble and post the box. Both are exactly the same game — the difference is who does the printing.
You may also want: a TV, laptop, tablet or just a speaker for the Inspector (you can read the script instead if you prefer), pens and paper; costumes and dinner (optional).
If downloading to print at home you will need: a printer and stapler (each booklet is roughly 16 pages long – or 4 sides of A4 folded in half); or if you prefer you can open the booklets on phones and tablets to save trees.
Reviews
From 10 reviews
Reviewers can earn Loyalty Points, and a discount code for sharing a photo, whatever stars they give. We remove spam and abuse, never a review for being negative.
We used the 10 player 1920s themed game for a birthday party in November. Fab customer service and fab game. Everyone was a potential suspect and there was no easy give away. We all had a great time! If anyone is doing the game with Connie Chiglie in it, comment as I went overboard on resources/ invites etc so i'll email them to you if you want them!
We all had a fantastic time but I wanted to drop you a note to say a MASSIVE THANK YOU! We all had a fantastic time and really enjoyed the story, everyone got into character and played their parts really well and half of us managed to get who the killer was (including me) So once again, thank you for all your hard work adapting it for our numbers and generally being oh so very helpful and we all can't wait for the next round!
Just wanted to give your game "Stiffed at the Speakeasy" five stars and comment that it give my dinner party a wonderful evening. This was my first time using Red Herring Games but it wont be my last. Well done
This was our first murder mystery game we have ever played and it was an excellent way to spend Hogmanay. Everyone had such a good laugh and we are looking forward to organising another murer mystery soon. We will definitely use Red Herring Games again as they were so helpful and efficient, we had a couple of people who dropped out at the last minute but thanks to the great service provided by Red Herring Games our Murder Mystery Party could still go ahead.
We have played several Murder Mysteries, on holiday in France in a farmhouse, and at dinner parties with friends. This is the first time we have used an on line site - it was easy to follow as an 'Internet Novice' and we will definitely use again. We needed to adapt to 11 players and this was all done for us - this was so much easier as they adapted the roles to accommodate the number of players. Previously we have had to have one person taking on two roles! Well done! We had a great New Year. We did have one problem - people were still carrying on in their assigned rolls the next day!!!!!!
We had great fun playing this for a 30th birthday. Was great that the person organising it had no idea who the murderer was and the sound files for the detective were great. Only 2 people got it right!
This is a fabulous game - really good scope for dressing up asmuch or as little as you want. We had a great New Year with this one, the receipe ideas were also great and not too expensive. Definitely would recommend this.
We played this on New Year's Eve with 4 adults and 4 teenagers and we all had a great time. The game was adapted for 5 females and 3 males and it worked very well - it really was a lot of fun.
A great game, lots of fun! Thank you Jo for adding the additional roles for the two young children. The kids were happy to play all through the game and never got tired (we could have even given them bigger roles than the adults had :-) thanks for your flexibility and customer service! You have a new repeat customer. Be-st regards from Switzerland
I hosted this party a few weeks ago for ten friends. It was a huge hit and all the characters were very interesting and the plot was fun and easy to follow. Two people guessed the murderer. I think it's great that not even the host knows the murderer until the very end. I originally bought for 8 characters and emailed a week before the party and they sent me the 10 character game. Red Herring was friendly and helpful. I have already ordered a different set and am looking forward to hosting another murder mystery party!
The small print
So you can ensure this is appropriate for your group. If you have specific content you are trying to avoid please do reach out directly so we can look at the game in more detail for you.
Before you buy
If you can’t find an answer to your specific question do reach out via email or phone.
Well, like everything it all depends. We usually say a standard dinner party with three course meal will take between two and three hours if you run it with less than 12 people. Each additional character adds approximately another six minutes to the time, however beware, the more people you have the harder it becomes to keep everyone on task! And what could have been a three hour game can stretch to five. There are sadly no “hard and fast” rules as it all depends on how much fun everyone is having. We’ve rushed through a 12 player game with a youth group in two hours, but equally have played a game at home with only eight people that started at 7pm and was still going at midnight! Event scripts are easier to guess as they are more “controlled”. Typically they last three hours with a meal.
For our small group dinner party games the minimum requirements if you are downloading the kit to print at home are about 4 double sided printed sheets of paper per character, a printer and a stapler. Any props and decorative touches are left entirely up to you.
If you want the game materials to look at their best then you might choose to have access to a guillotine, thick card for the booklet covers and a colour printer.
No. However most of our games are formatted in rounds to allow a three course meal. The only game format which works best without a three course meal is the Multi-room format.
We have adapted games in the past to work as “mix and mingle” affairs. If you’d like us to create something special for you to allow a mix and mingle event, then please email us.
Downloadable kit
If you’ve never bought a downloadable murder mystery game on-line before, or never played one (downloadable or otherwise) and want to find out more about it, then don’t worry – you aren’t the first. We are so confident in the quality of our games – when you buy from us you are guaranteed a great night in or your money back!
All our downloadable dinner parties are supplied with:
Printed kits
When you select the printed option – what you are asking us to do is print your game for you. Your game will arrive by post, printed, ready assembled and packaged in a box.
Printed kits are exactly the same as downloadable kits, in terms of content – it’s just that instead of you printing the game, we print the game for you and it will arrive ready to go. We also include envelopes for your invitations, and seal the inspector booklet in an envelope to prevent accidental viewing.
Because we print in-house we can customise even our printed orders, so please get in touch if you need something special e.g. a name adding to the invitations for a birthday, changing the image of a game. Minor changes can cost as little as £35.
If you aren’t sure whether you would like us to print your game for you – then we are happy for you to change your mind. Simply contact us after purchasing the downloadable game and we will arrange to print and ship your order to you after you make the additional payment.
You receive a complete "Party in a Box": Character booklets, Host Guide, Invitations, Evidence, and access to MP3 audio and video files for the Inspector’s narration.
6-20 player dinner party games will contain the following:
Please note postage costs are not included in the printed kit prices – these are added during check out.
The additional cost for printing (charged on top of the downloadable game price) is to cover:
If you would like us to customise your game materials prior to printing please get in touch with us directly prior to purchase so we can identify more clearly what you would like and build in any extra charges as needed.
Our content ratings are based on the ESRB rating scheme.
All of our games are suitable for a reading age of 10+ though they may contain language that is difficult for some children to comprehend.
All ratings are based on content NOT suitability, which means TEEN games are CLEAN games, rather than only being suitable for teenagers.
TEEN games are often games which are most suitable for mixed audiences, corporate and church groups.
It is worth noting that all our murder mystery games are rated TEEN or above as murder counts as violence for younger children. Some children younger than teens will handle the reading level of a standard murder mystery plot but parents may find the content inappropriate. Which is why we always detail the content of our games so you can make a determination of your own. If in doubt – take a look at the free sample booklet to check this is OK for your group.
It is possible for us to adjust the reading level on some games to make it possible for younger children to play – if you think you’d like this – please just email us for help.
TEEN games will contain “tame” plot lines. This can include plot lines like
MATURE rated games don’t necessarily mean the games contain explicit language, or sexual references. However the themes will be more gritty. To give you some examples:
If you are unsure which game is appropriate for your group – there are two things you can try. The first is to open up the “trial booklet” which will give you a sample character from a 6 player game. The second is to call us on +44 (0)2030 112 215 and we’ll chat to you about the content of the games and help you find the one most appropriate for your party.
You can request we adjust a 6 player game down to 5 players during the check out process. Not all our games easily adapt to 5, but we will do our best to make the game possible to play with a smaller number of guests.
Yes. Although all of our dinner party games are written with an even number of guests as standard. We can edit them so they can be played with an odd number of guests. This takes us an additional couple of days to produce your game.
On the game page, click to open the section “Have an odd number of guests?”, then choose the number of players and whether you’d like an extra male or female character. It adds a customisation fee to your order.
If you need other changes to gender ratios then do contact us. It may be possible but will affect your ability to use the pre-recorded inspector. As a general rule we cannot reduce to a ratio of male : female below 3 : 3. Any requests for custom amends DO take time. We do our best to accommodate them within 5 days, but it isn’t always possible in peak season. So we ask that you reach out first by phone or email so we can check our availability.
When you make contact we will be able to tell you whether your request is possible, what the total price will be and will be able to take payment over the phone, or provide an invoice to you to pay at your convenience.
We regret that we are not always able to alter the pre-recorded inspector speeches. Any alterations will be made to the inspector booklet, we can sometimes edit the MP3 too – but we regret we cannot edit the video inspector.
We understand how difficult it can be to organise a dinner party! Which is why, at no additional cost we will substitute your purchased game to one with a smaller number of players. However, please give us at least two working days to process a request!
If you ordered a custom printed kit – then we are happy to reprint your order, but unfortunately we will have to pass on to you the cost of reprinting your game. Standard “off the shelf” kits can be exchanged so long as the kit is returned to us undamaged.
If you expect you will lose just one couple, then give that couple (or yourselves) the last two optional characters on your game (you can check this by looking at a lower numbered game to see who is missed off). That way, if the couple can’t make it, everyone else can still come as the characters you originally asked them to be and we can easily swap the kit for you.
We can bespoke create “optional” guests with enough notice, fees will apply.
Check out this blog article for more information on how to adapt our games at the last minute.
Sometimes it is possible to customise and amend genders of suspects in games, but not always. This is due to plot tangles and how involved certain characters are within a game. It is best to contact us to check what is and isn’t possible if you need a different skew of genders. If it IS possible, we can explain the costs it will be to amend it ourselves. But if budget proves to be a constraint – we can send you the game in MSword so you can modify it yourself once you know it’s possible.
New? Not to worry! We deal with novice hosts every day.
Murder mystery evenings come in many different shapes and forms.
We retail kits for domestic/private parties, fundraising and for commercial users- and on top of all that we also event manage – so you’ve reached the “one stop murder shop!”
If you’re just looking to buy a dinner party then we have a range of DIY dinner party games.
If you are thinking of organising an event yourself for a large number of people we suggest you visit the page Choosing an event script. Which explains more about each format of large group game we stock.
We can take the stress out of party planning, and put the fun back into what can be a total headache by customising a murder mystery specifically to your party!
If you have an uneven mix of male and female participants, an unusual number of guests, or even just unusual guests, or a specific celebration in mind – then we are here to provide you with a personal service that will tailor a murder mystery game to your needs.
If you are looking for something fully bespoke then allow us to talk through with you what you are looking for and provide you with a free quote.
Your order confirmation email arrives straight after you pay, with a Download your game button. It signs you in to your account on our website, where each game is listed under Downloads: click a file to save it. Your games stay in your account, so you can sign in and download them again whenever you like.
If you were signed in when you paid, they’re in your account already.
When you click a file, your computer saves it, usually to its Downloads folder. If you can’t find it, search for the file name.
If you order a downloadable kit – the kit should be available instantly on a download link – and will also arrive via email with a link for you to download it.
If you order a printed kit or accessories and elect for standard service – this is shipped 48 tracked within the UK and Airmail outside the UK.
Approx arrival times for 48 hour tracked and airmail are:
If you elect for expedited shipping – we use a Courier or Royal Mail Next Day Delivery within the UK; and a courier outside the UK.
Approx arrival times on Expedited shipping are:
More like this
Par for the Corpse
The Pointy Knifers!
★5.0 · 1 review
Murder at Gatsby Manor
★5.0 · 1 review
Custom Written Murder Mystery Game - Allow 12 weeks for delivery
★5.0 · 1 review
Not quite right?
Answer three quick questions and we'll narrow it down to the ones that fit your group.
Gangsters, Guns and Garters